Open Threads

Start-class article · First seen: s02 · Last seen: s17

Open campaign threads as of end of session 17 — unresolved questions with current evidence and which character at the table cares. Sourced from the bible’s “Open threads” section and the recap “Open Mysteries & Unanswered Questions” sections. Resolved threads will move to a “Resolved” section as they close.

About this tracker

Each thread: title, current evidence (cited to session/line where possible), which player/character at the table cares about it, status. Threads are open unless explicitly resolved. New evidence on existing threads gets appended.

Egg current location

  • Evidence: The Egg was stolen by Aurelian forces in s15 [1]. The Egg was in Caelumn’s backpack; the backpack was pulled into the smoke by an unseen chain. The party are sailing toward the White Lantern Shrine (3 days’ sail) at end of s16 to meet Hett Varn and figure out a recovery route. Its exact current location is unknown.
  • Cares about it: All five PCs. Particularly Caelumn (held it), Hugo (pact-tied to quest completion).

Brioche’s significance to the egg quest

  • Evidence: Briochebane is a gold dragon wyrmling with unusual red-gold coloring (per DM ruling, post-s17), not chromatic; the egg did NOT resonate when Terry walked it past Brioche [2]. The DM phrased: “Sevryn’s magic may have misfired and accidentally sent you on the path to a golden dragon” [3]. Per Thomas Feld (s11), Aurelia and Vhal’Zarim hunted the chromatic dragons together long ago and “there are no chromatic dragons left on this side of the world to find.” Whether Brioche’s future hoard could affect the Egg is unknown.
  • Cares: All five PCs (the egg quest is the campaign’s main thread). Hugo (as the pact’s primary clause is egg-quest completion).

Vasquez’s parasite Mharos’s long game

  • Evidence: Mharos (also called Empraros) refused all bargains [4]: “There is no deal. There is only this. There is only me feeding on your delicious misery.” Stated aim [5]: “your grand purpose, which is bringing this world to its knees.” Wight in the upper quarry asked “What makes you so special? Why did it succeed with you?” [6], implying others were offered the same bargain and rejected. Buried by unnamed parties because it “would not stop spreading that weight” [7]. Weak to radiant damage [8].
  • Cares: Vasquez (host); Hugo (Black Mask awareness); the party at large.

The Black Mask’s offer to convert allies via soul contract

  • Evidence: The Black Mask [9] explicitly named Vasquez as a recruitment target: “I do have my eye on the one they call Vasquez. He has unlocked something that should probably have been locked away. But now that it’s free, it’s very enticing.” Mask claims [10]: “Once he’s dead, the demon has no hold of him.” Mask offered Hugo the upgrade to “champion eternal” if Hugo helps recruit Vasquez. Hugo has not committed.
  • Cares: Hugo (offered the deal); Vasquez (does not know yet).

The Wraith and the Ascendancy / Project Veilbreak revelation (ADVANCED s17)

  • Evidence: Hugo’s pre-experiment name “Corvin” revealed by Black Mask [11]. Project Veilbreak specifics from the altered sending stone recording [12]: 140,000 candidates, viscous-fluid blood replacement (50% died in 24 hours), biology rewritten at cellular level, two rounds of 1-of-100 arena combat, 7 survivors, narrated by the Project Veilbreak doctor. The Wraith is Hugo’s handler — appeared in dreams s7 (“Subject. Status report.”) with concern about leash weakening; the Black Mask names her “Rafe” in [13], the first personal name on transcript. Wraith’s exact relationship to Project Veilbreak remains uncertain. The Ascendancy named explicitly by Hugo [14]. Maelis Dirn recognized Project Veilbreak-style alteration on Hugo [15], but her exact relationship to the Ascendancy is unconfirmed. The Titan recognised Hugo [16]; the Titan’s full origin remains uncertain.
  • s17 advances: race-name confirmed as Voidforged [17]; first visual reveal — glowing veins / faintly glowing eyes / luminous-blue blood [18], L1475-1479); blood-vision imagery confirmed [19] — iron restraints, dark glass, chamber with no clean air; the “comply” whisper at the end of Mike’s ritual [20] suggests Hugo’s conditioning or leash may still be active or leaving magical residue (exact status unknown); DM-confirmed cross-source link — vision matches both the Black Mask’s s4 reveal AND the Titan environment from s7 [21]. Hugo’s voluntary disclosure to Mike [22]: “I am the result of some form of experiment. And that I’m one of a few survivors.”
  • Open: identity, geography, operations of the Ascendancy; the “lead doctor” is presumed to be Dr Flem Josenge, unless later clarified; status of Hugo’s erased family; Bella’s location. The wiki does not speculate on the remaining unrevealed survivors. The Ascendancy is connected to Hugo/Corvin and Project Veilbreak. It has shown the ability to act beyond one city, including reaching people from Aurelia. Its exact base and full relationship to Aurelia remain unknown to the party.
  • Cares: Hugo (primarily); Mike (knows now); the party at large.

Bella’s location

  • Evidence: Named by The Black Mask s4 as another Project Veilbreak survivor; Hugo recognised the name well enough to ask the Mask for her freedom as part of the pact terms.
  • Cares: Hugo.

Caelumn’s Platinum Order status reconciliation

  • Evidence: Caelumn is from Vhal’Zarim and carries a draconic bloodline tied to Bahamut’s flame. Exact dragon type unresolved (per DM ruling, post-s17 - do not confirm red). The s9 succubus’s failure-vision showed Caelumn at the Platinum Order “never being able to live up to his ancient draconic blood” (s9 paraphrase). Suggests an unresolved family/clergy conflict. Not yet developed in-fiction beyond personal flashbacks.
  • Cares: Caelumn.

Althea’s gorget significance

  • Evidence: Althea Stormsoro carries a silver-and-golden gorget with a burning gem “smashed in like a runic symbol” (s15 introduction). The reason the Aurelian patrol pursued her — they wanted to inspect it, she refused. Mechanical effect and origin unrevealed.
  • Cares: Althea (player Maliwana).

Maelis Dirn’s Duskwatch shipping network

  • Evidence: Forged shipping ledger from Maelis’s research desk s6, routing bio-gloom toxin through Duskwatch toward Velkris. Held by Hugo. The Broker advised selling it in Velkris to Silent Intake near “the Talking Skulls” entrance for significant reward [23]. The s16 sewer biogloom was confirmed as the same Umbrafall strain (Hugo’s medicine check [24]. The buyer side appears to be House Tallow-linked (the s16 transcript Whisper-rendered the buyer name as “Talaward” at [25], which is likely a transcript error for House Tallow). Possibly a Maelis-remnant cultivation site in the Eldwythe sewers supplying House Tallow trade.
  • Cares: Hugo (holds the ledger); The Broker (referrer).

Aurelia’s Nullstone production and what they’re doing to the abducted

  • Evidence: Mira Hale confirmed abducted to Aurelia for showing magical capabilities [26]. The Aurelian Paladin’s plate carried Nullstone runes [27] — anti-magic gear issued to officers. The party knows Aurelia has some way to detect or trace magic use, but the exact method is unknown. Aurelians arrived in Eldwythe in less than a day after the s12 fire [28]; wanted posters describe all five PCs including Vasquez who used no magic in s12 [29], 1464), implying intelligence/witnesses beyond pure arcane detection. Tieflings exterminated on sight in Aurelia [30].
  • Open: who within Aurelia is running the abductions; what they’re doing with the magically-gifted captives; how they detect magic; whether the various Aurelian abduction patterns share a destination (these cases appear to be part of a broader pattern of Aurelian abductions or disappearances, but the exact structure remains unknown).
  • Cares: Risa (sister); the party at large; Vasquez (tiefling-presenting, hat-of-disguised).

The Mind-Control Bookshelf in the Warrens (abandoned s6, still standing)

  • Evidence: Telepathic bookshelf in a Warrens side room [31]. Charmed Caelumn into grovelling worship; Hugo dragged him out by the leg with a nat-20 Strength check. Abandoned, never destroyed; contents unread.
  • Cares: Caelumn, Harvo (deceased), Terry.

The succubi (s8 forest vs s9 quarry) - RESOLVED (DM ruling, post-s17)

  • Evidence: Two separate succubi appear in transcript:
    • s8 forest clearing camp (the old-woman ambush) - defeated by Hugo + party; dropped the Charlatan’s Die.
    • s9 Black Vein Quarry crystal chamber - emerged from the cracked red crystal chamber, dragged each PC into a personalised vision, dominated Hugo who killed Harvo, killed in the same combat. Caelumn attempted Soulbinder bind at 2nd level - fizzled (CR3 vs L2).
  • Resolved: Two separate entities per DM ruling (post-s17, 2026-05-17). Kept as separate pages: succubus-s8 and The Succubus (s9).
  • Cares: Caelumn, Vasquez.

Aurelian magic-detection method

  • Evidence: Aurelians arrived in Eldwythe within ~24 hours of the s12 fire [28]. Wanted posters describe all five PCs including ones who didn’t cast in s12 [29], 1464). Thomas Feld s11: “people with magic rarely make it. Unless you’re part of the church, I guess.”
  • Open: The party knows Aurelia has some way to detect or trace magic use, but the exact method is unknown.
  • Cares: Hugo (asked the question in s14); Caelumn (visibly draconic).

The candied apple with dentures and the crooked broom

  • Evidence: Looted from the rock-candy study [32], L1258. Suspected to be Uncle Nibblecheek’s missing teeth and broom. Halfling note [33]: Nibblecheek can’t eat without his dentures — leverage opportunity. Both items were retained through s14 (broom used in Terry’s “new recruits” disguise). Per the DM (post-s16 correction): the candied dentures were returned to Uncle Nibblecheek before the s15 backpack snare and were NOT in the pack at the time of the theft; the crooked broom was in the pack and was lost with the rest of the contents (Egg, healing potions, gold). The thread is therefore a partial loss — the broom is gone, the dentures are returned, the leverage on Nibblecheek is discharged.
  • Cares: Caelumn (carried them); the party at large (the broom is gone, the leverage on Nibblecheek discharged by return rather than lost in the snare).

The injured man in the sewer basin (s16)

  • Evidence: Encountered in the Eldwythe sewers [34]. Wounded in a stone basin with overflowing biogloom roots. Asked for healing in exchange for information. Told Vasquez and Althea about a stash to the south-and-west. Vanished via invisibility potion before they could press for more [35]. Unnamed (DM correction 2026-05-17: this NPC was never named in play; an earlier wiki draft used “Jojo”, which is wrong and has been removed).
  • Stash status: The injured man claimed or implied there was a stash. Whether it exists and what it contains remains unresolved (DM clarification 2026-05-17). The party did not pursue.
  • Cares: Vasquez, Althea (only two PCs who met him).

The empty-feeling potion bottle from the sarcophagus chamber (s16)

  • Evidence: Found in the sarcophagus chamber chest [36]. Bottle “feels like it holds liquid” but appears empty. Untested.
  • Status: Per DM clarification 2026-05-17, do NOT identify this as an invisibility potion. The correct framing is: unidentified potion in a bottle that appears empty but feels filled with liquid. The earlier “speculated invisibility” framing was player-table guesswork, not DM confirmation.
  • Cares: Caelumn (carrier), the party.

Edith Applegarth’s betrayal of her brother Asger

  • Evidence: Children’s storybook in the rock-candy study [37] depicts a young Edith Applegarth visiting the cottage and “betraying her brother” to the hag in a child-bargain. The brother’s canonical name is Bubblegum Halfling (DM, 2026-05-17). Per DM clarification 2026-05-17: Edith’s betrayal of Asger is probably based on a real event, but the storybook is not an objective historical record. The bubblegum halfling never knew about the bargain. The party has not told him (and now never will: see status below). Last pages blank “because the story isn’t over.”
  • Status: Asger was killed in the Aurelian ambush in s15. The reunion thread is closed (impossible). What remains open: whether Edith herself ever learns of the death and her brother’s name; what the original child-bargain actually entailed; whether Edith is still alive under Aurelian occupation.
  • Cares: Caelumn, Terry (recall of Edith’s portrait).

Uncle Nibblecheek’s continued existence

  • Evidence: Uncle Nibblecheek surrendered s14 and let the party leave with Briochebane; he was NOT killed. He will remember. Future hostility likely.
  • Cares: All party members (he could ambush them later).

The Rat (Umbrafall information broker)

  • Evidence: Major Umbrafall information broker; only contacts you when he wants to (Broker [38]. Not yet contacted.
  • Cares: latent — could become major if/when contacted.

The unseen snipers that killed Earthwing the owl (two separate incidents)

  • Evidence: Two separate sniper attacks killed the owl on two occasions in two locations:
    • s8 quarry sniper: First Earthwing-form killed [39] in the Black Vein Quarry by a stealthed creature with a 20 stealth check.
    • s16 sewer sniper: Second/later Earthwing-form severed [40] in the Eldwythe sewers - “Something came out of the dark.” Vasquez and Althea later spot “something blended into the biogloom and the vines” on the ceiling [41].
  • Per DM ruling (post-s17), the s8 quarry sniper and the s16 sewer sniper are DIFFERENT occurrences, not the same entity. Both identities remain unknown.
  • Cares: Terry (owner of the familiar).

Aurelian “unauthorised studies” abductions (OPENED s17)

  • Evidence: Nella’s testimony at [42] — her husband was detained three nights before the s17 encounter by Aurelian road officers on the charge of “unauthorised studies”, after a household search turned up “old tide charts weather notes and a few pages copied from his father’s journal” [42]. Nella’s family is sailing north toward Gloamhearth with no food [43]. Nella herself is a lay Aurelian devotee — she made “the sign of Aurelia in the air” after Mike’s holy-presenting Mending [43].
  • Significance: Documents the “road offices” as small-town Aurelian arrest infrastructure and “unauthorised studies” as a charge category. Sits alongside the Mira Hale case as a second on-screen abduction-family example. These cases appear to be part of a broader pattern of Aurelian abductions or disappearances, but the exact structure remains unknown.
  • Open: Where Nella’s husband is held, whether he is alive, how many other families are affected, and whether the various detainee streams share a destination are all open.
  • Cares: Nella (off-screen); latent interest from the party (no commitment).

The Black Mask’s anti-Ascendancy motive (OPENED s17)

  • Evidence: In the s17 frozen-time audience with Hugo (visible to Hugo only), Black Mask claimed they could help with Hugo’s mind-control problem and spoke dismissively about the Ascendancy [44]. She also remarked on her own anti-end-of-the-world disposition — “Honestly, I’m kind of rooting for you guys. I don’t want the world to end” [45].
  • Open: The exact reason Black Mask is willing to act against the Ascendancy remains unclear. Hugo has not been told.
  • Cares: Hugo (only PC who knows; the audience was Hugo-only).

Steven’s previous (unnamed) pact patron (OPENED s17)

  • Evidence: Steven is already pact-bound by a previous patron when he joins the party. Two acknowledgements: “well, look, last time I signed a contract, I got nightmares. So I’m good” [46] and similar at [47]. The patron is not named on-transcript. The only concrete sensory cue is the smell of expensive tobacco smoke that accompanies his Pact-of-the-Blade dagger summon [48].
  • Open: Who is the patron? Are the nightmares the cost of the pact, a punishment, or a tool the patron uses for communication? Is the patron the same as any other extraplanar agent the party has encountered (notably, not the Black Mask — the Mask’s s17 interest was on Hugo’s line, not Steven’s)?
  • Cares: Steven (knows the patron); the party at large (does not).

The Vedalken spelling question - RESOLVED (DM correction, post-s17)

  • Evidence: Mike’s race (Vedalken) was rendered in the s17 transcript in at least six Whisper-side variants: Valdekin, Veldekin, Vidalcan, Vildulcan, Vildalcan, gudolkin, Vidolkin [49], L186, L785, L791-792). Known traits: blue-skinned, partially amphibious (1-hour underwater breathing), small stature, confirmed distinct from Voidforged per the DM’s [17] clarification.
  • Resolved: Per the DM corrections register (post-s17, 2026-05-17), the canonical spelling is Vedalken; all of the Whisper variants (Valdekin, Veldekin, Vidalcan, Vildulcan, Vildalcan, gudolkin, Vidolkin) were transcription errors. Origin / cultural background remain undeveloped in play but the spelling question is settled.
  • Open (residual): Are there other Vedalken in the campaign world or is Mike unique? What is the geographic / cultural origin of the lineage? These can fold into future world-brief expansion if Brian/Mike’s backstory surfaces in play.
  • Cares: Mike (carries the race); Brian (player).

Vasquez and Althea captured — CLOSED (departed offscreen)

  • Evidence: The s16 retcon clarified in session 17 [50]: Vasquez and Althea split off from the party at the end of session 16; the Aurelians closed in; the party chose to flee and left them behind; the two were captured. The Hat of Disguise (Vasquez’s attuned s16 item) was destroyed in the escape [51].
  • Closed: Per Chris’s post-s17 clarification, this is not an active thread. Vasquez and Althea are departed offscreen — the rescue is not the campaign’s direction. Their characters’ in-fiction status (captured by Aurelians, presumed alive, location unknown) is preserved as backstory but not as a hook. If a future session pivots the party toward rescue, the thread can be reopened; until then, treat as closed.
  • Cares (historical): Polar / Maliwana as departed players. The thread sits here for traceability rather than as an active mystery.

Water wolves’ purplish-blue blood (s17)

  • Evidence: The water wolves encountered in the s17 cold-water reef-line combat bleed a distinctive purplish-blue blood, first visible when Steven’s pact-dagger crit drew blood [52]. The colour visually echoes Hugo’s Voidforged luminous-blue blood as seen earlier in the session during Mike’s Detect Magic ritual [53].
  • Status: The water wolves’ purplish-blue blood resembles Hugo’s altered blood, but no connection is confirmed. Per DM clarification 2026-05-17, this is an unresolved visual echo — could be coincidence, shared origin, or unrelated frost-zone pigmentation. Treat as uncertain foreshadowing, not canon.
  • Cares: Hugo (subject of the comparison), the party at large.

s4 crow at Caelumn’s window

  • Evidence: After the s4 Black Mask audience, a crow pecked at Caelumn’s window [54]. Earlier wiki drafts speculated this was the Mask’s familiar.
  • Status: Per DM clarification 2026-05-17, this is a possible Black Mask familiar or spy. Not confirmed. Soften any claim that treats it as a confirmed Black Mask familiar.
  • Cares: Caelumn.

Brioche’s future hoard and the Egg

  • Evidence: Briochebane is a gold-with-red dragon wyrmling (DM 2026-05-17: gold dragon wyrmling with unusual red-gold colouring). The egg did NOT resonate with Brioche in s14 [2], L1293-1294). The egg is hunting chromatic-dragon essence; Brioche is metallic.
  • Status: Per DM clarification 2026-05-17, whether Brioche’s future hoard could affect the Egg is unknown. Keep open; do not over-explain deeper Egg metaphysics.
  • Cares: Hugo (egg-quest), Caelumn (carried the Egg), the party at large.

What is stirring in the Emberdeep

  • Evidence: Per the DM world brief: tunnels descend from beneath Khaldun’s lower mines into the Emberdeep, where miners pursue emberite veins “glowing with molten life.” Rumours say voices echo in those depths, warning of something vast stirring in the molten dark. The dwarves of Khaldun Forgehold ignore these whispers and keep forging, confident that “as long as their oaths remain unbroken, the Everflame will never die.” Whether the stirring is the Flame Below itself (a primordial force said to dream within the earth’s molten veins), something the Flame Below is dreaming of, an unrelated buried entity, or anthropomorphised volcanic noise is unconfirmed. World-brief canon; not yet referenced in transcript. Per DM world brief.
  • Cares: Latent — could become major if a future arc reaches the Emberpeak Mountains. Two PCs (Vasquez and Althea) are Khaldun-natives per [55], so the thread has a personal-stake hook waiting if the campaign goes there.

Sevryn’s foresight / “Everything is happening the way it’s supposed to”

  • Evidence: Sevryn correctly predicted Cholmondeley’s death (s2-s3 — had Earthwing queued for his replacement). Correctly predicted Harvo’s death (s10 letter L82: “I knew Harvo wasn’t coming back from this. I still sent him”). Sent Ruin via sealed letter at Harvo’s pyre s10 (Ruin then died s15). Telepathic affirmation [56] after the Egg was lost: “Everything is happening the way it’s supposed to.” Sevryn admits to using the party.
  • Cares: All PCs, the players, the table at large (the most active meta-mystery).

References

  1. ^ Session 15, line 500-504 — Inline citation.
  2. ^ Session 14, line 837 — Inline citation.
  3. ^ Session 14, line 1293 — Inline citation.
  4. ^ Session 10, line 383 — Inline citation.
  5. ^ Session 15, line 482 — Inline citation.
  6. ^ Session 9, line 495 — Inline citation.
  7. ^ Session 9, line 187 — Inline citation.
  8. ^ Session 10, line 827 — Inline citation.
  9. ^ Session 12, line 223 — Inline citation.
  10. ^ Session 12, line 235 — Inline citation.
  11. ^ Session 4, line 1670 — Inline citation.
  12. ^ Session 4, line 1312 — Inline citation.
  13. ^ Session 17, line 711 — Inline citation.
  14. ^ Session 12, line 194 — Inline citation.
  15. ^ Session 6, line 2538-2540 — Inline citation.
  16. ^ Session 7, line 614-615 — Inline citation.
  17. ^ Session 17, line 622 — Inline citation.
  18. ^ Session 17, line 666 — Inline citation.
  19. ^ Session 17, line 1483 — Inline citation.
  20. ^ Session 17, line 1485 — Inline citation.
  21. ^ Session 17, line 1494-1496 — Inline citation.
  22. ^ Session 17, line 1431 — Inline citation.
  23. ^ Session 7, line 745 — Inline citation.
  24. ^ Session 16, line 769 — Inline citation.
  25. ^ Session 16, line 776 — Inline citation.
  26. ^ Session 10, line 648 — Inline citation.
  27. ^ Session 10, line 1605-1644 — Inline citation.
  28. ^ Session 14, line 1567 — Inline citation.
  29. ^ Session 14, line 1561 — Inline citation.
  30. ^ Session 14, line 1619 — Inline citation.
  31. ^ Session 6, line 1041-1090 — Inline citation.
  32. ^ Session 13, line 1225 — Inline citation.
  33. ^ Session 13, line 1842 — Inline citation.
  34. ^ Session 16, line 1130 — Inline citation.
  35. ^ Session 16, line 1160 — Inline citation.
  36. ^ Session 16, line 1267 — Inline citation.
  37. ^ Session 13, line 1206 — Inline citation.
  38. ^ Session 10, line 471 — Inline citation.
  39. ^ Session 8, line 1762 — Inline citation.
  40. ^ Session 16, line 1068-1077 — Inline citation.
  41. ^ Session 16, line 1171 — Inline citation.
  42. ^ Session 17, line 973 — Inline citation.
  43. ^ Session 17, line 978 — Inline citation.
  44. ^ Session 17, line 717 — Inline citation.
  45. ^ Session 17, line 713 — Inline citation.
  46. ^ Session 17, line 567 — Inline citation.
  47. ^ Session 17, line 611 — Inline citation.
  48. ^ Session 17, line 1826 — Inline citation.
  49. ^ Session 17, line 37 — Inline citation.
  50. ^ Session 17, line 130-136 — Inline citation.
  51. ^ Session 17, line 134-136 — Inline citation.
  52. ^ Session 17, line 1840 — Inline citation.
  53. ^ Session 17, line 1478 — Inline citation.
  54. ^ Session 4, line 1352 — Inline citation.
  55. ^ Session 15, line 211 — Inline citation.
  56. ^ Session 16, line 1753 — Inline citation.